"Best Pizza in Jersey City"

Now Offering Takeout & Delivery (Best Price + Fastest Service)

Order Now

World Class Pizza Pies + Italian Bites





Some Things Happy Customers Have Said


  • Jenny S.
    Great pizza and friendly owner! We ate it twice while we were traveling in the area.
    • star icon
    • star icon
    • star icon
    • star icon
    • star icon
  • Steven S.
    Great service, awesome pizza. The whole package here at Pizza Pie... we traveled from Iowa today and found New Jersey's hidden secret right away. Thank you Yelp for helping us find this place
    • star icon
    • star icon
    • star icon
    • star icon
    • star icon
  • Lee S.
    First time here, all I have to say is.. this is how it's done! Loved both the meat lovers and chick bacon ranch. Make sure to go to town on the shakers too. The girl at the counter is the best. I liked her confidence knowing I would like the slice before it even hit the oven. That's the right attitude to have, stand by the product! Good!
    • star icon
    • star icon
    • star icon
    • star icon
    • star icon


  • restaurant icon

    Delicious Food

  • Delivery

  • heart icon

    Healthy Options

  • parking icon

    Curbside Pickup

  • timer icon

    Fast Service

  • handshake icon

    Friendly Team

sprout icon

Only Fresh Ingredients

We invest in quality ingredients to ensure our customers get the great taste we’re famous for. Because we believe that you
deserve the best.


heart icon

Made With Love

Our secret ingredient is passion. Everyone on our team is passionate about making your time with us as great as it can be
– from start to finish.


Pizza Pie La Cantina

About Us

Founded 10 years ago by the Garguillo Family in the Paulus hook area with a robust real brick-oven and rustic looking decor in a small side street – a hidden hole that serves as a takeout casual dining and crazy delivery business. Cute little seats and outdoor seating are geared towards accomodating the neighborhood’s corporate clients and new residents in this ever growing opportunity.

Until a year and a half ago, two brothers Hanish & Peter who have worked in a pizzeria while going to school always dreamed of having their own pizza shop where they could recreate old childhood memories of playing with pizza dough. They have a true passion for feeding people and making them happy with their unique creations.

Shortly after, this dream came true – but ultimately, their goal has always been to use the freshest ingredients and products available in the market and to provide customers the true Brooklyn brick-oven experience with New York Style Pizza (combined with some old school Chicago Square Sicilian flare).

Grandma’s Favorite recipes include our Meat Lasagna and our homemade entrées that are to rave for. Lastly, we believe that it’s the Love we put in our food (like our grandma) that make it so special.

We hope to see you soon! Ciao!